Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Students Protest Tucker Max lecture in student Union

Three Brockport students posted signs in an attempt to boycott the lecture

Editor-in-chief

Published: Tuesday, September 18, 2012

Updated: Tuesday, September 18, 2012 23:09

Tucker Max protest fliers

Cassie Negley/EDITOR-IN-CHIEF

Three different fliers were posted Tuesday night in a protest of BSG's announcement that Tucker Max will appear at the college in October.

Twelve hours after Brockport Student Government announced the controversial booking of author Tucker Max, three women students stormed the Union in an attempt to show fellow students what they believe Max stands for. 

Seniors Carrie Hellwig, Nicole Boothby and Kellie Engelmeier, all social work majors, posted typed-up quotes from Max' book in the Union after their night class. Student Union managers and employees worked quickly to tear them down and dispose of them before anyone saw as the Ballroom was full for a "Sex Signals" program.

The signs included such quotes as "It's because of women like you that in no language on Earth does the phrase 'smart as a woman' appear" and "That's the beauty of alcohol. If you don't remember it, it didn't happen." 

Of nine different quotes, seven of them included swear words inappropriate for print. Boothby said there were "hundreds of quotes we could have picked," and that these were just "skimming the surface."

"We chose the quotes because if someone doesn't know who Tucker Max is — say if I'm talking to person x and he says "Who's this Tucker Max?" and I say 'He's hilarious. Come to the show you'll laugh your a** off the whole time,' but if  hear, 'Well, he promotes rape culture and this is what he said,' as a woman I'm going to be like 'That's not OK,'" Boothby said. "That's a lot different than saying, 'Oh, he's funny.'"

Max is best known for his book "I Hope They Serve Beer in Hell." The first of four New York Times bestsellers, Max's writing is characterized as "fratire." He writes about his views on women, drinking (often to excess), insulting people and embarrassing sexual encounters.

Based on surveys from two and three years ago, the BSG executives booked him for the concert. The organization announced it shortly after 9 a.m. this morning. The Facebook post confirming the long-swirling rumors has 55 comments and 36 likes as of Tuesday night. BSG has also received Facebook posts, tweets and visits by students. 

Boothby said she went to talk to BSG President Samantha Wheeler earlier Tuesday.

Boothby said Wheeler told her the lecture is an opportunity to ask Max questions, including why he thinks it's OK to do the things he writes about. Wheeler also told The Stylus this in an interview Monday. 

"I don't give two [explicit] about why this piece of dirt thinks it's OK," she said. 

Hellwig said she doesn't want Max to come because he promotes the college culture of excessive drinking. 

"I've lived on campus for four years and I see what it's like on the weekends," Hellwig said. "People party Thursday through Sunday if it's a long weekend. It's just wild. I understand that you're in college, but there comes a point where you can't encourage that. That's what's so irritating.

"He's telling kids to keep doing what they're doing. [He's saying] 'It's OK, because hey, look at me, I'm a lawyer. Nothing will happen to you, you're invincible.' He's teaching men how to behave."

Hellwig, Boothby and Engelmeier said they had known Tucker Max was coming since last Tuesday as professors had announced it in class and urged their students to take action. They said they're leading a protest the night of the lecture. No one is sponsoring the protest in any way or giving money to the event.

Hellwig said organizations involved include: National Organization of Women, Student Social Work Organization, Women and Gender Studies Organization, SOUL, Voices for Planned Parenthood and various other students. Hellwig said they're trying to get students from other schools involved as well. 

While many in favor of bringing Max argue not everyone will be pleased all the time, the three women are quick to argue. 

"When you take it to a point where it hurts someone and causes damage, then it's too far," Engelmeier said. 

"As far as people saying, 'Well, this is BSG. You voted for this,' people have voted for presidents in this country who promoted segregation," Hellwig said. "Nazi Germany existed."

Hellwig, Boothby and Engeimeier said in the future they want to see BSG actively reach out to all students to see what the students want. 

"Getting elected to BSG is not a free pass to do what you want," Engelmeier said. "It's your responsibility to represent the student body."

Said Boothby: "What's that quote from Spiderman? ... With great power comes great responsibility."

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

1 comments Log in to Comment

TSP
Wed Sep 26 2012 19:04
As a parent of a College at Brockport student, I am greatly disappointed in the Brockport Student Government's (BSG) selection of Tucker Max as a guest lecturer, and equally so in the inaction of the college's administration in permitting the event to proceed. To say BSG and the administration are practicing hypocrisy of the highest order is not an overstatement. To begin, the presentation makes a mockery of the college's Women's and Gender Studies Program which aims to advance gender-equity causes. Second, featuring Max makes your messages about the dangers of drugs and excessive alcohol consumption ring dangerously hollow. Third, essentially condoning Max's jokes about the handicapped are a slap in the face to Brockport's renowned program in Adapted Physical Education and its history as the host of the Special Olympics.

So, what rationale is there for exposing students to someone who has denigrated women, made light of drinking and drugs, and ridiculed the handicapped? Well, as reported on the Rochester Democrat & Chronicle's website on September 21, BSG president Samantha Wheeler says that she was aware that the choice of Max would cause controversy, but hoped that his talk would promote discussion among students. "If they disagree, they can ask that he justify things that he has said before." With all due respect Ms. Wheeler, are you serious? You and your fellow board members really believe that Max's comments can be justified? Should any student not be expected to disagree with his vulgar, demeaning, and hurtful words?

In the same Democrat & Chronicle article we read that Dave Mihalyov, spokesman for the college, said that student government is a separate, not-for-profit organization, with its own budget that allows for programming. "While the administration may not agree with this programming choice, we are not in the business of censorship," Mihalyov said. Again, with all due respect, are you serious Mr. Mihalyov? It is an insult to free speech for you to cowardly hide behind the false excuse that not allowing Max as a lecturer would be an act of censorship. As Americans, we all know that Max is pretty much free to say or write whatever he wants. What we also all know is that The College at Brockport or any other organization does not have to provide him a forum for his messages. Would the college provide a forum for someone who spewed forth hatred towards a racial or religious group?

College at Brockport President John Halstead, for whom Mihalyov is obviously speaking, is the one who really needs to take a stand and cancel Max's lecture. When families send their children to college, there is an inherent trust that they will be guided responsibly. While this should absolutely include being exposed to different and even controversial points of view, hurtful and degrading messages have no place on a college campus. As SUNY graduates, my wife and I are proud that our two children attend SUNY schools, but are embarrassed at the publicity that Brockport is receiving because of Max's scheduled lecture. President Halstead, in reference to the US News & World Report's 2012 "America's Best Colleges" guide, surely you could not have been thinking of Max when you said, "This national recognition is a reflection of the great work that is done on a daily basis by our students, faculty, and staff and the College's commitment to student success."

I've read where Max has turned his life around. So, rather than learn anything worthwhile, students attending the presentation will hear Max's usual trash, or perhaps unjustifiable reason(s) for his past actions or maybe even an admission that they were wrong. Yet, for such dribble, BSG is paying Max $20,000, more than half of its annual budget for lecturers; money that is derived from the $96 mandatory BSG fee that every student pays. Brockport and the entire SUNY system have no right to cite budgetary challenges and constraints when raising tuition and other fees if this is how some of the money is being spent.

I urge BSG and the college administration, led by President Halstead, to do the right thing and cancel Max's presentation. And, I encourage all Brockport students, family members, faculty, administrators, and anyone else employed by or associated with the college to demand the same. If Max really has turned his life around, he should absolve the college of any payment obligations to him. And if he doesn't, I suggest asking professors and administrators to take up the cause and each donate $5 or $10 to partially or fully cover the $20,000 speaking fee, or in this case, non-speaking fee. Cancelling the lecture would send a great message that The College at Brockport truly stands behind the programs it offers and the messages it conveys.

Tom Pinto
Brockport Parent

You must be logged in to comment on an article. Not already a member? Register now

Log In